Police officers locking the gate of a police station, during a protest on Tuesday, condemning the rape of a 23-year-old woman on Sunday(Photo: Tsering Topgyal/Associated Press Via IndiaInk Blog)
Police officers locking the gate of a police station, during a protest on Tuesday, condemning the rape of a 23-year-old woman on Sunday(Photo: Tsering Topgyal/Associated Press Via IndiaInk Blog)

Rape and the Hypocrisy in Our Outrage

On Sunday evening, a girl gets beaten and raped in a moving bus in Delhi. She then gets thrown off the bus; tossed on the highway like garbage. The girl had to undergo critical surgeries to survive. She is currently, on a ventilator, and can only communicate with her family and the police by writing.

Police officers locking the gate of a police station, during a protest on Tuesday, condemning the rape of a 23-year-old woman on Sunday(Photo: Tsering Topgyal/Associated Press Via IndiaInk Blog)
Police officers locking the gate of a police station, during a protest on Tuesday, condemning the rape of a 23-year-old woman on Sunday(Photo: Tsering Topgyal/Associated Press Via IndiaInk Blog)

What can we do to wipe out this menace? What does the country really need to eradicate the crime of rape?

Some say we need stricter laws. Let’s take a look at the present laws on rape. Thanks to Bollywood movies, we know rape is a criminal offence under Section 375 of the Indian Penal Code. Let’s picture a scenario and look closer.

A man rapes a woman. A case is filed. Now, because the law is blind, in a court of law, one would need to provide evidence for a crime. Let’s say the accused man has a history of raping, molesting or harassing women, that history cannot be brought up during the trial. Why? Because Section 54 of the Indian Evidence Act disallows that. What it does allow is for the accused to bring up his past in case he wants to prove his “good character”. However, the same rule would not hold true for the woman. Section 146 and 155(4) of the same Act allow the defense to question the woman about her sexual history. The basis upon which the defense can argue include:

1. The victim is a woman of loose morals.

2. She had previous sexual relations with other people.

So what really is the law suggesting here? A woman who is not a virgin does not have the right to file a complaint against being raped? So do we just need stricter laws or do we need to look at rape in a different way?

Rape is Not Sex

A pair of skinny jeans and a sleeveless blouse do not hypnotize men to rape women. Short skirts are not provoking. What is provoking, however, is rape jokes in movies like 3 idiots. What is provoking is a dancer in an item song, being flocked and touched by men and shown to enjoy the whole thing. Not to forget the lyrics of those songs.

The message: Women enjoy being touched by strangers.

What is provoking is the songs of Honey Singh that the youngsters so love to hear. What does it provoke? It provokes the self-esteem and anger of some people who have somehow managed to remain human in a society with rape culture.

So when people listen to songs like ‘Balatkaari’ or songs with titles that I’m afraid I can’t even write for I’m writing for a college newspaper, when these songs (read noises) and ‘creative artists’ like Honey Singh (a misogynist who seems he cannot get over a breakup after being dumped) are free, out there with their music being played aloud and danced to; if Honey Singh can scream his tonsils out then why is there a need felt by the Censor Board to mute words like ‘condom’ in Hindi movies? Why are cartoonists put behind bars? Why are M.F. Hussain’s paintings banned but not Honey Singh’s songs? Isn’t the Indian society trying to tell us something here? What it is trying to tell us is that you cannot disrespect Gods, but you can disrespect women. Honey Singh probably feels the same impunity that most rapists feel.

I had once read somewhere that most men would rape if they had the opportunity and if they knew for sure that they could get away with it. That pornography is not sex, it is sex inequality turned into sex for the pleasure of men.

Why care about a girl being molested on camera? Why care about those ‘lovely and heart-warming’ remarks that ‘innocent Romeos’ pass on girls at every corner? And why care about a girl being raped and thrown off a bus?

In this particular case we probably care because she is in a critical medical condition. But if she had not been in a critical condition, it is quite possible many would have criticized her decision to go out for an evening movie shows. Maybe the country just pays heed when the act of rape is supplemented by inhuman torture and physical injury. The country cried for Aruna Shanbaug. But what made them cry was the aftermath of rape and not the rape itself.

When rapists and molesters strip a woman in broad daylight and make a video of the girl and of themselves molesting her, what do you see in their faces? Their faces depict a certain kind of power that they seem to derive from the girl’s pain. And then there is a certain kind of smile that their grossly lips curl into. The smile is the pleasure they get by putting somebody else in a helpless situation. That is the moment when those men stop being men; stop being human.

One needs to take a stand. And I don’t mean one should go out on the streets and protest and change the world overnight. But do something that would change the world some day, to take a stand in our own living rooms. When we get furious when we hear a rape story but then also enjoy a rape joke or a rape song, it just makes us look like a bunch of hypocrites.

To reiterate, rape is not sex. And yes, there are bad men out there. Men who think a girl gets up every morning to dress up for them, slips into a skinny pair of jeans for them, wears her hair in a certain way for them, takes a certain road for them, travels in a certain bus for them, and therefore chooses them as their ‘sex’ (rape) partners.

When it comes to rape, there are mainly two types of people. There is a set of people who get outraged by the crime and protest on the streets; while there is another set that stay at home and spend their day tapping their feet to a Honey Singh song.

About R. Nithya

R. Nithya (2013) is a special correspondent for Jamia Journal. She can be reached via email at: nithya@jamiajournal.com

Check Also

[Prof. Talat Ahmad over the mike [L-R] Dr. Junaid Haris, Dr. Mohammad Sajjad, Mutiur Rahman Madani, Er. Aslam Alig, Tauqueer Jamaee, Dr. Khalid Mubashshir; March 19, 2016 (Photo courtesy Manzar Imaam]

JMI VC Assures of Opening Distance Learning Centres in Seemanchal

19 March; Sehratola (Purnea), Bihar: During a seminar on educational backwardness of Seemanchal, Prof. Talat ...

3 comments

  1. Comments made on JJ Facebook page:

    Mohamed Wasif: I dont think that the rape joke in 3 idiots can provoke a potential rapist to commit the crime, although I dont have much understanding about the mind of such a monster. I think we all watch movies, we are not provoked in this way. We are not provoked in the same way. Surely, something else is wrong in their heads.

    Nithya Ravi: Wasif, my point was NOT to say that movies or songs provoke rape because that will also mean that short skirts could provoke rape. So that was not my point. Potential rapists will rape anyway. My point is that movies, songs, and rape jokes create a “rape culture”.

    A rape culture is where rape is normalized exactly what the comment above describes. Rape jokes are part of the rape culture that makes rape seem so normal and the jokes seem so funny; the culture that sexualizes rape and derives pleasure from it; the culture that validates sexual assault of women by claiming freedom of expression—freedom to tell jokes or pornography; the culture that blames the victim- she must have wanted it. She must have enjoyed it. Or she must have provoked him. Rape culture turns sexual assault into sex and enjoys it.

    What is important to understand is that in a rape culture there might be one rapist but there are many ‘participants’ (who are usually not rapists.)

  2. Tell me about it. I can see my facebook wall filled with posts that depict the anger in people over this rape case. They all want these rapists to be hanged or killed, howsoever.

    But, the funny thing is that some of them are my college/school friends, who, a few years back, were so awed by the song by Honey Singh (Badshah, Ch**t), that they knew every single word by heart. This also includes me. Even I was a big fan of this song at that time.

    But near about ONE F***ing MILLION views of this simple video [Link Deleted by Admin]
    .. shows that the sexual repression is taking its toll. And, is bound to explode.

    For anyone who might disagree with this blog post (and/or my comment) must, must, must, listen to the song above. I don’t think you can differentiate between the intentions of the rapists with the lyrics of this song.

    And, mind you, no one ever objected to this song. It was a huge huge huge hit in the youth of India. And, honestly, I liked it too (but, songs like these just seem foolish to me now. Probably, I’ve changed with time for the better).

    Change yourself, leave the rest.

  3. NOW WE CAN SEND our SUGGESTIONS to Govt. made committee for AMENDMENTS in LAWS related to RAPE. BUT
    “Do we REALLY need to change the Law or the Attitude from the roots?”
    When we buy a toy for a boy its a toy gun and for girl its a barbie …..here it starts we are unintentionally creating the society where we put our girls not to be equal to boys, they are suppressed and inhibited with thought that the boys are having the power in the society to do whatever they want…When will we teach our girls to be resilient to withstand in this society then we will not see any more rapes or oppression….and of course the law and order should be in place.

Leave a Reply